Below is a comparison table between QChartist TA and TradingView, with an emphasis on features, philosophy, and platform limitations, including the censorship concerns often experienced by users of TradingView:
📊 QChartist TA vs TradingView: Comparison Table
| Feature | QChartist TA | TradingView |
|---|---|---|
| Platform Type | Desktop software (standalone) | Web-based + desktop app |
| Indicator Freedom | ✅ No censorship on indicators | ❌ Indicators can be removed if deemed “too good” or “non-compliant” |
| Open Source / Customization | ✅ Highly customizable (open-source) | ⚠️ Limited scripting freedom (Pine Script within rules) |
| Proprietary Indicator Publishing | ✅ Full control over your tools | ❌ Indicators can be banned, hidden, or removed |
| Community Sharing | ✅ Unrestricted sharing via files or repositories | ⚠️ Subject to review and moderation |
| Backtesting Tools | ✅ Powerful built-in backtester | ⚠️ Backtesting available but constrained |
| Data Ownership | ✅ Full control over local data | ❌ Data controlled and stored by TradingView |
| Cost | ✅ Free or donation-based | ⚠️ Free tier available, but advanced features paid |
| Offline Use | ✅ Works offline | ❌ Requires internet access |
| Execution Integration | ⚠️ Limited (manual or 3rd-party only) | ✅ Integrates with brokers for live trading |
| Chart Types | ✅ Standard + uncommon chart types | ✅ Excellent chart variety |
| Ease of Use | ⚠️ More technical, less user-friendly | ✅ Very user-friendly and polished UI |
| Mobile Access | ❌ No mobile support | ✅ Full-featured mobile apps |
| Censorship / Platform Control | ✅ No restrictions on content | ❌ Subject to platform censorship, terms, and bias |
| Community Exposure | ⚠️ Small user base | ✅ Large trading community and exposure |
🔍 Key Insight
- QChartist TA gives developers total freedom to create and share profitable, unconventional, or proprietary indicators without censorship or fear of removal.
- TradingView, while powerful and popular, has increasingly taken a gatekeeper approach by removing indicators they consider misleading, unrealistic, or too effective (which can affect their business model or challenge paid partnerships).
📝 Conclusion
If your goal is freedom, privacy, and uncensored distribution of powerful and potentially profitable indicators, QChartist TA is a superior platform. TradingView, although more modern and widely adopted, enforces content control that can limit innovative or unusually successful trading tools.