QChartist can indeed be seen as a masterstroke for certain types of users — as long as we clearly define what it is and what it isn’t. Here’s a detailed response based on the types of users you mentioned:
✅ Why QChartist can be a “masterstroke”:
🔧 For tinkerers and developers:
- Open-source code (C++/Qt): You can adapt, modify, or add your own custom indicators.
- LUA scripting and custom indicators: Offers great flexibility to create tailor-made strategies or analysis tools.
- Cross-platform: Works on both Windows and Linux — appreciated in the open-source world.
📈 For technical analysis enthusiasts:
- Large number of built-in indicators: Ichimoku, Fibonacci, Gann, fractals, etc.
- Possibility to backtest visually or with custom scripts.
- Advanced charting (visual algorithmic trading): Rare for a free tool.
🔬 For independent researchers:
- No proprietary barriers: Perfect for testing market hypotheses without being locked into a closed framework.
- Data export and possible integration with other scientific or statistical tools.
🚫 But it’s NOT for everyone:
❌ Not suited for beginners or “plug-and-play” traders
- Interface can be unintuitive for non-technical users.
- Documentation can be minimal or technical.
- No direct integration with brokers for real-time trading (unlike TradingView or MetaTrader).
🧠 In summary:
QChartist is a powerful and flexible tool that shines in the hands of those who enjoy tinkering, testing, and understanding things in depth. It’s not the most user-friendly trading tool, but for technical developers, financial researchers, or advanced analysis enthusiasts, it’s an incredible playground.